Businesses often use the terms labour hire and contracting interchangeably. In practice, they can represent very different workforce arrangements, with different responsibilities, commercial considerations and levels of risk.
Both models can provide flexibility. Both can help businesses access capability without immediately increasing permanent headcount. But choosing the right model depends on what you actually need: additional people operating within your business, or an external provider delivering a defined service or outcome.
Understanding that distinction before engaging someone can prevent problems later.
Labour hire and contracting solve different problems
At its simplest, labour hire is generally about supplying people.
A labour hire provider engages workers and supplies them to a client business. The worker performs work within the client’s operation, while the labour hire provider retains responsibility for matters associated with the worker’s engagement and payment.
In Queensland, for example, businesses supplying labour hire workers generally need to hold a labour hire licence, and businesses using labour hire must engage appropriately licensed providers.
Contracting is generally different.
A genuine independent contractor operates their own business and provides services to another business. The relationship is typically more focused on the delivery of an agreed service, project, task or outcome rather than simply providing another person to operate as part of the client’s workforce.
That distinction sounds straightforward. In reality, the way the relationship operates matters significantly.
When labour hire can make sense
Labour hire can be particularly effective when a business needs additional workforce capacity but does not necessarily want to recruit permanent employees.
Common situations include:
- Temporary increases in workload
- Project mobilisation
- Specialist skills required for a defined period
- Employee leave coverage
- Short-term operational gaps
- Rapid workforce expansion
- Uncertain future workforce requirements.
Consider an engineering business that wins a major project and requires two additional engineers for nine months.
The business wants those engineers working with its existing project team, using its systems, attending internal meetings and operating under the direction of its project leadership.
That is the type of requirement that can naturally lend itself to a labour hire or on-hire arrangement.
The client receives access to the capability it needs, while the labour hire provider manages the employment or engagement framework behind the placement.
When direct contracting can make more sense
Contracting may be better suited when the requirement is genuinely for an independent business or specialist to deliver a service.
For example, a company may engage:
- An independent consultant to redesign a commercial process
- An engineering consultancy to complete a technical design package
- An IT specialist to implement a defined system
- A marketing agency to deliver a campaign
- A project consultant to produce an agreed set of deliverables.
The key difference is that the contractor should be operating as a genuine independent business rather than simply being labelled a contractor while effectively working as an employee.
The Fair Work Ombudsman says that determining whether a worker is an employee or contractor can involve factors including control over the work, financial risk, provision of tools and equipment, ability to delegate or subcontract, working hours and the expectation of ongoing work. For many constitutionally covered businesses, the assessment now considers the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship, not simply the wording used in the contract.
The contract alone does not solve the problem
One of the most common mistakes businesses make is assuming that putting the words Independent Contractor Agreement at the top of a document determines the relationship.
It does not.
Likewise, a worker having an ABN, issuing invoices or operating through a company does not automatically establish that they are a genuine independent contractor.
How the arrangement operates needs to support the contractual position.
For example, consider a specialist engaged as a contractor who:
- Works exclusively for one organisation
- Works fixed hours determined by that organisation
- Is directly supervised by a company manager
- Cannot delegate the work
- Carries very little commercial risk
- Uses the company’s systems and equipment
- Performs essentially the same role as permanent employees
- Continues in the arrangement indefinitely.
That arrangement deserves closer examination regardless of what the agreement calls the worker.
Compare the two models commercially
The decision should not simply come down to the hourly or daily rate.
Labour hire:
A labour hire arrangement may incorporate costs associated with:
- Worker remuneration
- Superannuation where applicable
- Statutory employment obligations
- Workers compensation
- Payroll administration
- Payroll tax where applicable
- Insurance
- Compliance
- Recruitment and screening
- Provider margin.
The headline rate may therefore look higher than directly engaging an individual contractor, but part of that rate reflects responsibilities and risks being managed by the provider.
Independent contracting:
A genuine contractor may quote a day rate, hourly rate, project fee or fixed price.
However, businesses should still understand their own obligations.
Using a contractor does not automatically remove payroll tax, workplace health and safety, superannuation or other potential obligations. Different regulatory tests can also apply for different purposes.
The cheapest apparent workforce model is therefore not always the lowest-cost model once risk is taken into account.
Five questions to ask before deciding
Before determining how someone should be engaged, ask:
- Are we buying someone’s time or buying an outcome?
If the requirement is essentially another person joining the team and working under your direction, labour hire may be more appropriate.
- Who controls how the work is performed?
Greater independence over the manner in which services are delivered can be more consistent with genuine contracting.
- Does the person operate an independent business?
Look beyond the ABN. Consider whether they genuinely operate in the market, carry commercial risk and provide services independently.
- How long is the requirement likely to continue?
A three-month project requirement can look very different from someone performing the same role continuously for several years.
- Where does the risk sit?
Consider employment classification, payroll tax, insurance, workplace obligations, commercial risk and administrative responsibility rather than comparing rates alone.
The right model should follow the requirement
There is no universally superior workforce model.
Permanent employment, fixed-term employment, labour hire, independent contracting and consultancy arrangements can all be appropriate when used for the right purpose.
Problems tend to arise when a business decides how it wants to classify a worker first and then attempts to make the circumstances fit that classification.
A better approach is to start with the work.
Understand what needs to be delivered, how the person will operate, who will control the work, how long the requirement will exist and which party should reasonably carry the associated responsibilities.
Then select the engagement model.
Know before you engage
The structure of an engagement can have implications well beyond the initial recruitment decision.
APSG works with businesses to assess workforce requirements and determine practical resourcing options across permanent recruitment, contracting and flexible workforce solutions.
Need additional capability but unsure which engagement model is appropriate? Contact APSG to discuss your workforce requirement.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal, taxation or financial advice. Businesses should obtain professional advice regarding their individual circumstances.